[Watch] Bridging the Gap: Empowering Underbanked Communities with Instant Payments

By

Fed Communities Staff

Photo of a person using their online device to process a digital payment with banking graphics and a payment successful green check mark.

Access to affordable, reliable payment services is essential to household financial stability—yet many consumers still face barriers. Today, 14.2 percent of US households are considered underbanked, meaning they rely on alternative nonbank financial products even though they have a bank account. This gap presents an opportunity for financial institutions and community development organizations to design solutions that better meet consumers’ needs. One promising avenue is instant payments, which can help replace costly, less‑regulated alternatives.

To support this work, the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston has developed the Inclusive Payments Resource Center, an online hub offering data, insights, and tools to help institutions understand underbanked populations and strengthen their payment strategies. The Center features a new, national level interactive data tool that highlights the geographic distribution of underbanked households, along with survey findings that shed light on why consumers turn to high‑cost nonbank services. These insights can help financial institutions communicate the benefits of instant payment products and tailor offerings to the communities they serve.

During this webinar, participants benefited from a range of informative conversations designed to deepen their understanding of financial inclusion and instant payments:

  • Interactive Data Tool Demonstration: Attendees saw a live demonstration of the new interactive data tool, which provides valuable insights into the geographic distribution and characteristics of underbanked households.
  • Instant Payments Discussion: The webinar featured a discussion on how instant payments serve as a viable solution for replacing expensive nonbank payment services, highlighting their potential to improve affordability and accessibility.
  • FedNow Insights: Participants gained practical perspectives on instant payments from FedNow’s Nerissa Aslantas, exploring real-world applications and implications for financial institutions.
  • Financial Institution Perspective: A practitioner from a consortium of financial institutions shared his experience, explaining why the data tool and other available datasets focused on underbanked populations are crucial to delivering responsive financial services and building partnerships between banks, non-profits, and government.

Related resources:

Speakers:

Connecting Communities: Bridging the Gap: Empowering Underbanked Communities with Instant Payments (video, 59:11)
Dowload presentation slides (2 MB)


Sergio Galeano

Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome. Thank you for joining us for today’s Connecting Communities webinar, Bridging the Gap: Empowering Underbanked Communities with Instant Payments. I’m Sergio Galeano, a community and economic development advisor with the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, and it’s a pleasure to be here as moderator for today’s session.

Access to safe, affordable, and reliable financial services is a fundamental building block of financial stability. Financial inclusion encompasses a wide range of efforts that help to ensure that individuals and families have the tools they need to fully participate in the economy and build financial security. While significant progress has been made, millions of Americans continue to face barriers that limit their access to affordable financial services.

Today’s discussion brings together experts who are working at the intersection of payments, data, and community development to explore practical strategies for addressing those challenges. We’re excited to share new insights, including innovative data resources and perspectives on how instant payments can support more inclusive financial outcomes for all Americans.

To help us unpack all of this, we’re fortunate to have with us today the following three experts. Jason Andrade, he’s a director of research and membership engagement at the Partnership for Financial Equity, where he drives Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), research initiatives, and strategic financial institution and community partnerships, designed to expand credit and capital access for low- to moderate-income communities across Massachusetts. Concurrently, Jason also serves as a director of financial planning at Nubian Square Investment Advisors, overseeing financial planning and wealth management strategies for the firm’s clients.

We have Nerissa Aslantas joining us, senior product manager on the FedNow business development team at the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. In this role, she serves as a liaison between the FedNow product and customer-facing teams to assess market needs, identify strategic opportunities, and promote instant payments awareness. Nerissa joined the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston in 2017 as part of the strategic planning office actually in New York, with previous experience in philanthropy and public policy research.

Finally, we have with us today, Brian Clarke, deputy director in the regional and community outreach department at the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. He is currently leading an effort to assess the impact of real-time payments on low-income users and small businesses. Brian has done previous work identifying opportunities for banks, credit unions, and Fintechs to design products that help people achieve financial goals while avoiding unnecessary fees.

Now, before we get started, just a few housekeeping items for everyone in the audience. Views expressed during this session are those of the speakers and are intended for informational purposes. They do not necessarily represent the views of Fed Communities or the Federal Reserve system. Microphones have been muted, but please make ample use of the Q&A feature in Zoom throughout the session, even now if you came in with a question in mind. We promise to get through as many of those as possible during the Q&A and panel discussion.

Now to keep the conversation going and engage with us wherever you get social media, please use the hashtag #ConnectingCommunities and you can visit fedcommunities.org for a variety of community development articles, resources, past webinars like these, and data from across the Federal Reserve system. And finally, this session will be recorded and in about two weeks’ time you’ll get the presentation, video, and podcast on the fedcommunities.org website.

Now, before I turn it to Brian who will kick us off with today’s first of three presentations, I’d like to ask you all in the audience a question just to get to know everyone across the country who joined us. It should prompt up right now on your screen and the question is, which best describes your organization or role? You’ve got a couple answers there to choose from. Hey Brian, thank you for joining us today and sharing your expertise. The floor is yours.

Brian Clarke

Great. Can everyone hear me? Sergio, can you hear me? I just want to make sure I’m going good. Great. I am so happy to be here today to show you a little bit about what we’ve been working on here at the Boston Fed as it relates to inclusive payments.

To give a little bit of context, a few years ago it was announced that the Federal Reserve is going to build an instant payment network, which allows banks to set up with each other instantly. I work in a department at the Boston Fed that focused on issues in low- and moderate-income communities. So I got really excited because I know that a lot of alternative financial services rely on issues of speed or settlement where people need money instantly, need money to arrive at its destination instantly. And so we began an undertaking to work with our colleagues that are building the Instant Payment Network to talk about how we can embed issues of financial inclusion and payments inclusion into some of their process. So I’m really excited to show what we came up with and where we’re going with this.

Another impetus for this or another baseline for this is that the Federal Reserve policies for the provision of financial services states that the Federal Reserve must consider the needs of financial institutions and the public when offering financial services. So I think this is a project that’s right at the intersection of those two things. Because we talked to financial institutions and they said, “We’d like to know more information about those folks that are underbanked in our communities and underbanked populations.” By highlighting those populations, we think it’s helpful showing the needs of some of the public that their payments needs and how we can elevate those and bring those into the conversation.

So what I’m going to do now is I’m going to show you a website we built that is a reaction to that. What we heard from financial institutions and from people we talked to out in the field. It is called the Inclusive Payments Resource Center. It lives on bostonfed.org and this is it. I’m assuming you can see this. Yeah, it says I’m screen sharing. So this is it. This is the Inclusive Payments Resource Center. It’s something we’re really excited about. I’m going to go through it. I’m going to focus on two areas when I go in here. You’ll see the first one is this one I’m down here. Where are the underbanked areas? It’s a data tool.

We consider this to be kind of the who, who’s underbanked and where. So what you’re looking at here is a data tool that uses information from the FDIC survey of underbanked. This is a survey that’s biannual. It occurs every other year. And so what we did was we wanted to make it so that people could look into geographies that are maybe a market area or somewhere where you operate, and be able to get a better look at underbanked households in the areas. This is a sum of a few years of the survey to try to get better observations.

So I’m just going to take you through this quickly, highlighting a couple of things in here so you can see it. So you see, you can click on a state, you can get to it changes and it shows you some of the demographics. I have age selected here and then it shows you the age of folks that are underbanked. This is where you can select unbanked, underbanked or banked.

Level setting just very quickly. I realize I started throwing around those terms without defining them. A household that’s considered banked is if it has access to a bank account. It’s considered underbanked if it has access to a bank account, but also indicates that they’ve used alternative financial services in the past 12 months. And it’s considered unbanked if they do not have access to a bank account. Alternative financial services are non-bank financial services, and I will get into some of what those products are in a second as we go into here. But this is where you get a chance to look at the geographies that may be interesting to you.

So what I’m going to do is select in here, zoom in. I’m drawing now, which is not what I wanted to do, but I’m going to keep going. So this is where you get to Kansas. So you look at Kansas and this is age and you can select by different demographic variables. So if you wanted to look at the income of underbanked households in Kansas, you’ll see that it ranges from the highest cohort is from 15 to $30,000. If you wanted to look at race and ethnicity, we have that as well. So there’s things like that that are in there and that you can look at.

And so we think this gives a better clue into who the underbanked populations are in certain areas. And will hopefully be helpful as you’re thinking about who that may be.

The other thing you’re able to do in this is look at certain MSAs within the sample for areas that have enough observations that we felt comfortable putting them on here. One thing I will say about this is, there are a few things that you see, this one we have here, there are a couple blanks where there just aren’t enough observations. We’re working on a solution for that, something pretty cool. So stay tuned, but I just want to show you how this tool kind of works.

So let’s go down here to the D.C. area and see you’re able to select. If you hold the control button, you’re able to select multiple MSAs. And these are some contiguous ones in the D.C. area. And I’ve got some things selected in here that are going to give us a better look around Washington D.C. and Baltimore about what products people are using. So I talked before about alternative financial services. Here you’re going to see what some of those alternative financial services are. Things like auto title loan, check cashing, online money transfer services, pawn shop loans, payday loans. These are all products, again, that people use when they need money usually pretty quickly, or they need to get money somewhere where the person that’s receiving it wants to know that the funds are good. So when you think of a money order, think of something like that.

Now I’m going to go and get into quickly the results of a survey that we did of alternative financial services users. So we surveyed alternative financial services users to ask them what they liked about their experience with alternative financial services. You can look at a survey and you’re saying to yourself, “Well, people are using alternative financial services. Why are they doing that?” And I think that that’s an important question to ask because a lot of times there’s very rational reasons behind why people are using alternative financial services.

They’re often avoiding other fees elsewhere if they didn’t use them. So think about a late fee or an overdraft fee if you are trying to avoid or get money into your account to make a payment. If you don’t get the money there in time, you’re going to get a late fee. So you’re saying, “All right, I’ll pay this fee to pay it even though this fee’s higher than it should be or I think it should be. But I’m avoiding a late fee from the place I’m billing that I have the bill for that could be as high as $30 or $40.” So you’re making a very rational decision, but at the end of the day, it’s still probably more than you wanted to spend on a simple payment service.

So we asked people what they indicated what they liked. And so again, being clear about when the funds are going to arrive at their destination is critical. People like knowing that when they use an alternative financial services to pay a bill, that they’re going to get confirmation that the bill was paid and that they trust the service to get the funds there pretty immediately.

We had a lot of folks that use earned wage access, which is a product where you access money that you’ve already earned before your payday, your traditional payday. This is again, another product that helps people kind of plug gaps. As we all know, payday doesn’t always line up with the day your bills are due. So people are looking for ways to smooth out some of those short-term liquidity issues and returning to some of these other services.

Money orders continue to be the most frequently used alternative financial service. I think this is really interesting because as you think about an instant payment network, you might think that instant payment network and money orders have nothing in common, but that’s actually not true. A money order is usually requested by the person you’re paying because they want to understand, they want to know that the funds are there. It’s not going to bounce a check.

In an instant settlement environment, you know that the money is good because it has to settle instantly. And so it alleviates some of those issues. You’ll see here retail bill pay, which is a non-bank bill pay. So going to a location and doing it, a money center, some of those things, usually a storefront or kiosks in convenience stores and things of that nature.

Paying rent the day it’s due and paying bills last minute are the use cases that are ranked highest by AFS users in our survey. People just want to be able to get money where it needs to be immediately. And in a world that’s changing rapidly with technology, we think that that’s a reasonable thing that people should request. And finally, you look here at some of the earned wage access things, people tend to make the request for earned wage access pretty close to payday. And we think that that indicates that people are trying to, again, plug these holes in their short-term finances and get access to money so that they can move it around.

And then you’ll see here, there’s a couple of slides on charts on how people are paying for things, going to the biller website online, and then overdrafts. So again, what I think you’re seeing is people struggling, making payments and ends meet with incomes and outflows. And we think that there’s a good story here between who is doing this. So you look at the data tool, you see who and where people are that are underbanked and unbanked. And then you go to our survey and you see why they’re using these tools.

And then in a minute I’m going to turn it over to Nerissa and she’s going to talk a little bit about the promise of instant payments, and why we think it’s an important tool for closing some of these gaps. I know I have to ask the question. So we did ask a polling question at the beginning and now I get to see the results of it. So where’s everyone from? I’m very heartened to see that most folks are from community development organizations, nonprofits. We believe that this is a tool that practitioners can use to get some more data on their locations.

Again, we’re going to enhance the tool to make it so that hopefully you can get into some even smaller geographic locations. So we’re hoping that’s helpful. And then we see financial institutions, that’s great. We’d love to hear from finance institutions about are you able to use the tool to build a case for offering instant payments to the populations that we think it could benefit the most? So hopefully you’re listening, you’re paying attention and ready to have that discussion.

My email is on the website, so feel free to email me anytime if you want to talk about this, have any questions. I love to talk about it. I usually can wrap up quicker than this. Or sorry, I talk for longer than this. I’m trying to keep it short.

My next thing to do is ask the next polling question. So you see it on your screen. What do you see as the biggest barrier to financial inclusion in your community? Is it lack of access to affordable financial products? Is it trust in financial institutions? Is it the cost of services and fees? Is it limited awareness or financial education? Is it access to digital tools or internet or is it other?

Nerissa Aslantas

Hello everyone. I’m Nerissa Aslantas. I’m a senior product manager on the FedNow team at the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. Before I begin, I’ll sort of just let you guys know that one of the reasons I was originally excited to join the FedNow team is because of the promise that instant payments has to better serve the needs of communities who are living paycheck to paycheck. And now I get to help lead the FedNow’s financial inclusion efforts.

Let’s see how you guys responded to the poll. Okay. So what do you see as the biggest barrier to financial inclusion in your community? It looks like most people are saying limited awareness or financial education and a close second is sort of lack of access to affordable financial products and trust in financial institutions. I think that’s in line with what we’ve been seeing as well.

Okay, let’s move on to the next slide. All right, so imagine this, you’re working the night shift as a home health aide for an elderly woman who lives a few towns away. Every day you leave work around 7:00 AM, you’re tired, you’ve had a 12-hour shift, and you drive about 45 minutes to get home as the sun rises, making it home just in time to bring your son to school.

You make around $17 an hour. Gas costs around $4.19 per gallon, last time I checked. Your gas light comes on. You drive a little bit because you know your payday isn’t for a few days and you just went grocery shopping yesterday. But you stop at a red light and you’re like, “Let’s see, let’s check my account balance.” There’s about $6 left in your account. You try not to panic, but then you remember the agency that you work for just rolled out this new benefit called earned wage access, which allows you to access the wages you’ve earned right after your shift.

So you decide, I’m going to pull into the nearest gas station. You transfer enough money to buy the gas and you make it home just in time to get your son on the bus to get to school. Next slide.

Unfortunately, this is a reality for many Americans. About 85% of employees across all industries report feeling stressed about money. 38% of households reported difficulty paying at least one bill last year. And one in five have less than two weeks of liquid savings available to them at any given time. Over the past few years, earned wage access has emerged as a lifeline for people who are living paycheck to paycheck. We see it being used across industries, but particularly by those who are working in retail, hospitality, or in the gig economy.

Providers of earned wage access services report that users predominantly spend these funds on essential needs like food, fuel, and housing. And in a recent survey, we found that 79% of workers said they would be willing to switch to an employer that offers earned wage access. Brian already showed you the tool. There’s a lot of use in how it’s being used, but a lot needs to happen behind the scenes to make sure that the funds are available to send in real time on demand to those who need them.

With instant payments, payroll service providers can work with financial institutions and employers to instantly transfer funds to an employee’s account, which ensures a quick and seamless access to earned wage access for workers. Next slide, please.

FedNow is the Federal Reserve’s instant payments rail that was launched in 2023 to help modernize the US payment system. FedNow works behind the scenes with banks and service providers to clear and settle payments in real time. Enabling financial institutions of every size all across the country to offer instant payment services to their customers around the clock.

And it’s not just the speed that makes the network valuable. It also operates 24/7. It’s currently the only fed payment rail that does this. And as a credit push service, the payments are initiated by the sender. So all funds are final and irrevocable and the payer has control of when the payment is made and you know exactly when it settles, so there’s no guessing about if the beneficiary received it. Next slide please.

So why does this matter for financial inclusion? For me, I think instant payments offer an opportunity to the financial industry to develop innovative products and services that better serve the needs of the public in an affordable and accessible way. When payments are processed instantly, consumers and businesses get more control over their money and it makes it easier for them to manage their cash flow.

With instant payments, bills no longer need to be paid two to three days in advance because payers can be confident that their funds will arrive immediately. So I think Brian already mentioned, but paying rent the day it’s due is particularly attractive for low- and moderate-income households. The ability to make time-sensitive payments can also reduce the risk of overdraft and late fees, or even service disruptions in the case of a utility bill. And it can also reduce reliance on costly alternatives like payday loans or check cashing services, which can charge fees like $20 for a single transaction.

For those who are living paycheck to paycheck, the 24/7 availability of funds also allows for greater financial flexibility, which is critical for overall financial wellbeing, especially during times of economic stress, unexpected expenses, or during an emergency.

After about three years in operation, FedNow has about 2,000 financial institutions and over 50 service providers on its network across all states and all sizes. Some of the use cases that have been gaining the most traction over the service includes earned wage access, which we’ve already mentioned a number of times, and online marketplace seller payouts. So if you’re providing a service or if you’re selling goods online as a side hustle, instant payments can allow you to get your funds immediately.

For anyone who’s ever worked a job that has unpredictable wages, this is particularly helpful in managing irregular income streams more effectively. As you can see on the slide, there are also potential for a number of industry verticals. So small businesses is a good example. In underserved areas, these small business owners can benefit from improved cash flow management when they receive their funds instantly, and that can potentially reduce their need for short-term financing.

Insurance disbursements are another area where instant payments can have a great benefit. So imagine somebody who just got in a car accident, getting their money quickly could be extremely beneficial. And instant payments has the potential to add efficiency and speed to the delivery of public sector benefits as well. So you can think unemployment checks, veterans benefits, or even financial aid disbursements. Next slide.

Last year, the US Treasury integrated FedNow into its digital payout solution, which enables federal agencies to make instant payments directly to individuals that need financial assistance. For example, FEMA is now using the system to deliver disaster relief funds to victims within seconds rather than in weeks or in days. This not only cuts delays caused by traditional check mailing processes. Imagine if your house got burned by a fire, you don’t have a mailbox, how are you going to get a check mailed to your house? It really helps people who are impacted by natural disasters like floods, hurricanes, fires, get the financial relief faster when they need it the most.

And we’re just getting started. The real opportunity in instant payments really is driving the industry to create better products that improve financial flexibility, expand access to affordable financial services. We don’t really want to just recreate old systems using this new technology. We want to use the new technology to better serve and identify ways to expand financial opportunity. And if we can do that, we can build a financial system that will work well for everyone. Thank you.

I’m going to pull up the next slide for the poll. Where do you think instant payments can have the greatest impact for underbanked consumers? And I’m going to pass it over to Jason.

Jason Andrade

Great. Great. Thank you, Nerissa. It’s really a pleasure to be here. I’m Jason Andrade, as Sergio mentioned, the director of research and membership engagement for Partnership Financial Equity. Really excited to talk a little bit about our organization, some research that we recently conducted focused on better understanding trust in banking systems and in our communities. And kind of relating that work and tying it to instant payments. So can move on to the next slide, the presentation.

So as I mentioned, I’m from an organization that’s based in Massachusetts called the Partnership for Financial Equity. We’re really a community development nonprofit built to support and build relationships between financial institutions, community leaders, nonprofit organization, and government as well. We like to say that we’re a unique organization and we have a unique voice in that we used to be, or formerly we were known as the Massachusetts Community and Banking Council. And we were formed in the 1990s following a research report actually from the Boston Fed that discussed some troubling lending or lack of lending that was happening in certain Boston communities.

Some large financial institutions were maybe not lending to communities of color and in certain communities. That created quite an uproar in communities of color, and there was a lot of community organizing and pushback that was discussed in media. So financial institutions wanted to create a space where these community groups could have a voice and they could have a voice, and they could convene to discuss how is investment actually happening in our communities and how can we improve those outcomes?

So with the support of Mass bankers, our division of banks, the governor’s office, MCBC was formed to provide that space. And we kind of operate in three major focus areas. Again, to convene, we host quarterly committees. We have five committees, three issue committees, one on mortgage lending, small business lending and banking services. And then we have two other committees that are kind of private discussion spaces, one for CRA officers at banks in Massachusetts and really in New England to discuss upcoming regulations and changes. And how they can better partner to support CRA initiatives in our CRA community council that’s reserved for our nonprofit partners to discuss bank mergers and updates. And have those groups kind of talk to each other on an ongoing basis.

We also are a research organization. For 25 years, we’ve been producing mortgage lending and small business lending reports. And in this past year, which I’ll talk throughout this presentation about, is a trust and banking survey that really tried to understand what does it mean when we discuss trust? We know that’s one of the major issues that folks are not connecting with financial institutions because of trust. But what does that actually look like? Is it the services? Is it how folks feel reflected in the institution? So we wanted to explore to better understand that.

And then connecting. We want to connect, again, these institutions that are doing good work with partners who need that kind of support, or clients who are looking to connect with low cost and safe products. So we launched the Bank On Massachusetts Coalition about two years ago. And we also host an annual convening where we provide awards to great partnerships that are happening between banks and community groups.

And PFE has been a leader in a lot of initiatives that we think are pretty impactful. In ’94, we launched basic banking, which is a precursor to Bank On, the first state-based voluntary low-cost account program, which we have a number of institutions that still participate. We had a voice and we were part of launching the Massachusetts Home Ownership Collaborative, or CHOPA. Which sets the standards for housing counseling in first time home buying programming and classes.

We also ran a campaign, an anti-predatory lending campaign called Don’t Borrow Trouble, which was eventually picked up by Freddie Mac and used as a national campaign. And then in 2007, our research led to Massachusetts being the first state to expand its regulation in CRA to cover mortgage lenders as well, third party mortgage lenders. Next slide.

So as I mentioned, we wanted to better understand what does it mean when we hear from communities and customers around? We don’t trust institutions or we don’t trust financial institutions. So we, in partnership with a really wonderful researcher who was formerly at the Urban Institute and now is a PhD candidate at the USC Price School, Amalie Zinn. We kind of constructed this research report to better understand, again, this trust and better… Because there’s little research that really explained what it means and how it’s sustained.

We also wanted to understand how much do people with accounts trust banks? So these are folks who maybe have banks underbanked or unbanked for sure, but underbanked folks. And what are their issues? Or how do they feel about their banking services? The OCC also, I think part of why we kind of explored this was I think the OCC or EMLI had written a letter to the OCC proposing this Trust in Banking Survey or unbanked and underbanked survey that the FDIC produces every other year, if it could be something that is run more annually.

And PFE felt like that was a space because there wasn’t a lot of traction on the national level that we could fill in this data gap. And we kind of wanted to have a research report that was really actionable. We care really about the practical steps. So what are some actionable insights and ideas that community groups and financial institutions could use to really improve their services or build that trust in their community?

We surveyed 642 Massachusetts residents with a household income under 80,000. I will also mention we did this with a great partner, MassINC Polling Group, who really, they were the ones who conducted the survey and helped us really with Amalie construct the questions. We also wanted to over sample for the Latino community, which is the largest minority group in Massachusetts. And we did this in September 2025 and it was an online survey both in English and Spanish. Next slide.

So, what were some of the high level findings from that report, especially as we talk about relevancy with instant payments? We did find that folks do trust banks overall. At least in the folks that we surveyed, 85% somewhat trusted financial institutions, but that trust was shallow, right? Only 25% responded that they strongly trust banks. There was a number of factors there, poor experiences in the past or lack of understanding.

Although unbanked numbers nationally and in Massachusetts are trending lower and lower every year. I think in Massachusetts around 4.2% similar or around that. Don’t quote me on that exact statistic. But we found that low income residents or 8% of low income residents are unbanked, so three times the state average. We also found that 50+% use alternative financial services and that rose for the Latino community to around 75%. And I’ll talk a little bit of why we think that is. And then 34% of unbanked residents say account fees are too high. So we also discussed a little bit what kind of fees folks are thinking about in there.

And what we found is that services were important as a part of this. Nerissa and Brian hinted to this. This kind of innovative base that financial institutions could really lean into. 47% of folks preferred to bank by mobile app. That was a much higher percentage in the Latino community at 59%. Although there was a real, we did hear from folks that having a physical location is important, especially when issues come up. And is a space of a value add where traditional financial institutions can really differentiate their services. As mentioned, again from Brian and Nerissa, speed was very important. 24% of unbanked need quick access to cash, and 12% said checks just clear too slowly.

Transparency. I think folks sometimes say transparency, what does… Well, check cashers tend to have very clear signage on their walls and on their doors of the exact fees they’re going to charge. In the views of some folks, that’s a lot easier and clear and easier to expect than maybe a minimum maintenance fee, right, that could happen and folks are not necessarily always sure how much they need that account or when that fee is charged. And sometimes the timing of it can be really poor.

And then service gaps. Latino residents use check cashers at almost four times the rate at white residents. So there was a real delta between these community groups, and we wanted to also ask a little bit about alternative services that were being provided. Next slide.

I also wanted to bring up, I think this would be a great time before I talk about this to bring up the survey result. And we’re going to discuss that. Great. So our question here is where do you think instant payments can have the greatest impact for underbanked consumers? And I think the majority of folks said all of the above, and we tend to agree in our survey as well, kind of reinforced a lot of this. As Nerissa just mentioned and Brian, it can have a tremendous impact in a number of these areas.

Just tying this to our trust and banking research report, which I encourage folks to check out on our website and look at it in more detail. It does expound on a number of items. But 53% keep an account to receive paychecks. So getting paid is an important piece of this. Wages, gig earners, tax refunds, benefits, making those funds available, receiving that is a core reason why folks go to check cashers.

48% said keep an account to pay bills, right? Especially in this digital world that we’re living in. Obviously it’s a great thing in that it allows easier access to payment and folks really lean into that, that convenience factor of it. So same moment payments help avoid late fees and overdrafts and the cost that most drive. And those costs really, really drive distrust amongst communities, especially if they feel like it was unexpected or unfair.

And then 59% of Latino residents prefer to bank by app. And there’s a number of factors here, but we think about certain communities and remittance services, right? They might have family and communities and other places that they want to send money to. And obviously digital apps now are providing the opportunity to do that more and more. Again, Nerissa and Brian have talked about this. And the promise of instant payments can really be a game changer for certain communities.

And what builds trust? Flat upfront pricing is really important in this conversation. Again, as I mentioned, check cashers and some of these alternative financial service providers, they’re really clear around what fees they’re charging and what that is going to look like. And to some people, and especially the folks we surveyed, that’s a really, really helpful thing.

Fraud protection is important and building in this idea… And no fees is really important. That’s why we’re really supportive of bank on certified accounts that don’t allow folks to get into trouble with overdraft and have low or no monthly fees. That’s an important aspect of building trust. Making sure folks are in the right types of products and accounts. So I think with that, I’m going to turn it back over to Sergio. Thank you.

Sergio Galeano

Jason, thank you so much for rounding us out. And a big thank you to you, Nerissa and Brian for those really great presentations. I invite all of you to come back on camera. Let’s chat a little bit. This was a great collection of presentations on a new tool from the Boston Fed to help expand awareness and data usage around financial inclusion. Understanding FedNow, instant payments as really necessary financial infrastructure and technology driving the change. And through you Jason and your organization, impact, action and what collaboration and that concerted effort over years and decades could really bring out Massachusetts and across the country.

So many questions. Let’s chat. Let’s start with Brian, but also a reminder for everyone in the audience, feel free to submit any questions. We’ve got around 15 to 20 minutes of discussion and would love to loop in any questions that you might have here during the discussion. Hey, so Brian, really love this Inclusive Payments Resource Center. It’s a really necessary resource and I really appreciate, I think the audience sees as well. Pairing the survey on how people use alternative services with the tool so that you can understand the context.

And when you see the various reasons, it really lets people understand how we can result in financial exclusion and what’s needed to get to inclusion. How should we think about those findings alongside this tool? So for example, when you’re looking at patterns and geographic usage or thematic by the type of fees people are avoiding, or the reasons for which they use alternative sources. What might a tool like this inspire community development organizations, nonprofits to pursue strategies to fill in those gaps and address any of the issues that the survey and the data might illuminate?

Brian Clarke

Yeah. So I think when we originally envisioned doing something like this, we talked about how the ideal user is probably a financial institution that’s trying to make the case for offering instant payments to their customers, and wants to know more about who it can help within their institution. So if you’re underbanked, you have a bank account and you’re using alternative financial services, that means within the institutions in the United States, the financial institutions, those transactions are leaving your institution to go somewhere else and people are paying for it.

A light bulb should start going off there. So it’s like, okay, where are the people located? What products and services are they using? That’s the data tool. The survey is why? Why people are using. And then the use cases on the website are about what can you do about it at a finance institution?

However, I think it’s important that if you’re sitting practitioner, nonprofit, you’re hearing these anecdotal stories or hearing stories of people coming in, look like all of the above were the use cases for instant payments. Start talking to your local financial institutions. If they aren’t offering instant payments, ask them about it. I think one of the things I get tired of hearing is that when I talk to financial institutions, they say, “Well, people aren’t asking for this.”

People don’t know that it exists. If people know that there’s an alternative to pay, and they start asking their finance institution about it. That removes one of the arguments from the finance institutions. They can’t come to us and say, “People aren’t asking for this.” People need it. That’s what we’re trying to show. People need this and that’s what we’re trying to show.

Sergio Galeano

No, there’s a huge bridge between active efforts that are observable around financial inclusion and a lot of the background technology like instant payments that might go taken for granted that maybe a consumer doesn’t see. But is equally important for banks to understand as they continue to drive innovation.

This tool launched this year. As this gets used and you put it in the right hands for action and for great strategies to bring financial inclusion to communities in Boston, Massachusetts, and the greater country. What kind of additional information could you imagine a tool like this eventually taking on as well? What new partnerships would help bring in more data that’s necessary?

Brian Clarke

Well, that’s a good question. I mean obviously we see it. But what we’re going to start with is we’re going to try to add more geographies so that people can get a closer look within their own area that they serve, and be able to select more minuscule geographies. Right now, because of the way that the survey is done, we’re confined to the largest metropolitan statistical areas in the country that have enough observations where we feel comfortable publishing it.

So it really limits our geographical reach. I think if you’re in a less popular state, you can look at the state level and kind of glean some things about why your state might be different. In the future, I can see, we’ve talked to folks about the Philadelphia Fed has a fantastic tool that looks at bank desert. So it looks at all the branch locations in the United States. Layering in some of the other tools from around the system that are also geographic based. So the whole Federal Reserve system is pulling together to address the issues of financial inclusion. I think that’s something I could see happening.

But I’m going to turn this back to your audience in a way. It’s like we want to hear from people that look at this and say, “Well, I really wish it showed this or I really wish it showed that.” Because we can come up with what we think people want to see, but I think it would be really helpful, especially after seeing the mix of people that are here from different organizations to hear from the public. What would they like to see?

If you’re at a financial institution, I’d like to see this. If you’re at a nonprofit, I’d like to see this. If you’re a practitioner, local state government, I’d like to see this. I’m not saying we can do it all, but the more that we know about what people want to see, then we can at least start thinking about how to do it.

Sergio Galeano

That’s right. That’s right. And as a reminder, everyone in the audience, the link to the Inclusive Payments Resource Center is in the chat and we’ll also share the link to the Philadelphia tool that Brian mentioned, and he also shared his email. Please reach out seeking feedback on the tool and further usage. Brian, thank you. You’ve helped us introduce us to this great resource center.

And I wanted to tie it back to Nerissa on some of the practical technological solutions underpinning this work through instant payments. And Nerissa, you’ve also got a couple of questions actually from the audience that I think would be a great start. Someone actually asked about the logistics of using FedNow, if it’s in an app. So here is, what are the barriers? Well, there was a question on the industry adopting FedNow, if you want to address that. But also again, a reminder for folks like the logistics, how does FedNow actually appear?

I think I heard that most consumers won’t see this. It’s more infrastructure that’s embedded in financial tools and in banks. But if you wanted to quickly cover that and any industry barriers for the audience.

Nerissa Aslantas

Yeah, sure. So I’ll say our role as FedNow is we are doing the behind the scenes with the rail, right? So we’re not the payment experience. We’re not a wallet, we’re not a checkout button, we’re not a pay by bank, we’re not a mobile app. We are basically the plumbing behind that sits behind all the payment experiences. So the real value gets delivered by banks, Fintechs, processors, businesses. All those different people are the ones who are building the experiences on top of the rails. And we actually rely on them to bring innovation to market.

Barriers, I would say definitely, I don’t think the barrier at this point is technology. The technology exists, we have the infrastructure. Really, we really need more adoption and innovation that’s built on top of the rails. So from my perspective, I would say there’s three things that need to happen. The first is awareness. So in my mind, this is a win-win. There’s lower costs, better products for consumers. And there’s new markets and there’s new business opportunities that are available to financial institutions. But there needs to be awareness on both sides, right? It has to be both the financial institutions have to understand the business case, but on the consumer side, they have to really understand and trust these new payment options.

The second thing I’ll say that has to barrier that would have to be overcome is really access. So many financial institutions are turning this on and getting set up with FedNow Instant Payments. But they need to be able to enable this for all of their customers. So many of them are starting slow. They’re starting with, let’s say, their corporate customers. And then they’re thinking about how do we expand this to retail and more everyday consumers? So getting it turned on for everyday people is going to matter.

And the last thing I’ll say is consumer experience. So I touched on that before, but the technology is not the value proposition. I can talk here all day about ISO 20022 and the benefits of it. You guys are going to all fall asleep. But if you say you can get your money faster, people are like, “Oh, okay, that makes sense to me.” So financial institutions are the ones who know their customers best. Obviously, every financial institution has a different set of customers. They’re the ones who are going to build the experiences that solve real customer problems. And so we need to figure out how to do that at scale.

Sergio Galeano

Oh, thanks for that. Scalability is what would really bring impact in financial inclusion. So I wanted to ask you, you covered a lot of technology and the infrastructure. But on measuring outcomes, I know that in financial inclusion, especially with banking services, it’s really important to count metrics like new accounts, new interactions, transactions. But how do we distinguish successful adoption of instant payments technology from actual improvements for the people who are the beneficiaries of all this in financial inclusion? So what outcomes should we as a financial inclusion field be looking for beyond the number of institutions or transactions?

Nerissa Aslantas

Yeah, it’s a really good point. I mean, the real measure of success isn’t how many instant payments are sent. It’s going to be how people have access to affordable financial tools. If they have greater financial flexibility. If there are fewer situations where a financial hardship is caused simply because of the timing of the payment. Some of the things that we’re looking at is how many people are still using alternative expensive financial banking options like payday loans? Average time to funds for critical types of payments like insurance claims, disaster relief, that kind of thing. The number of affordable products that are even available in the market that are for and accessible to underbanked populations. And other customer outcomes like number of overdrafts or late fees.

But again, it’s pretty hard to have a direct causality between instant payments and financial health. We have some interesting research that’s being done across the Federal Reserve system. So there’s been some work about financial health metrics generally. So that is basically about measuring a consumer’s ability to weather financial shocks, manage expenses, plan for the future. So not just how many payments are they making in a given period. We’re thinking access is a great start, but it’s more than access.

I will also say that we currently have a cross-functional group established within the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. And they’re digging into one particular use case, which is earned wage access, which you’ve heard a lot about today. But the goal of that research is really to understand how earned wage access can be designed to maximize the financial health outcomes for vulnerable populations. And I’m really looking forward to seeing what comes out of that group in the future.

Sergio Galeano

Oh, thanks for that. No, I’m glad you closed on earned wage access because for anyone who might be new or less informed on financial inclusion. I mean the presence of checks, cashiers, let’s say in low and moderate income communities is probably the biggest marker of financial exclusion where you have this kind of third party servicing what a bank typically would. And most people might assume that it’s only because they want the funds before their payday, which is very true based on the survey and what we know from a research perspective. But there’s so many other ways that people interact.

And I wanted to turn to Jason to dig into that. Through your organization, you’ve worked with so many families and individuals across the state of Massachusetts for decades on this work, and I wanted to tie in the conversation on the context of the need for these tools to inform financial inclusion strategies. Where people are excluded, what still needed to happen, whether in banking and instant payments. But just kind of step back and talked about folks’ lived experience.

So from your experience, what factors shape how households choose financial services? Whether it’s a bank or any kind of fee or other tool. And what do you think that institutions sometimes misunderstand about the underbanked and unbanked households and how they actually make financial decisions and interact with these tools?

Jason Andrade

Yeah. No, that’s a great question, Sergio. I think what I’ll first say is families and households are not monoliths. And I think often sometimes with the data, it can be easy to bunch people into specific groups, right, or certain types and behaviors. But households, communities, ethnic groups, they have different views of how they look at these things. And some of the data that we found, right, there are real generational differences in how people bank. Many younger and newer to banking customers are mobile first, while others still want to branch and people they know. Although our data also reinforces the importance of an in-person branch in having that touchpoint available.

Second, I think people go where service is better for their needs, and this is something I really want to reinforce. Sometimes that is an alternative service provider. If a money order is cheaper at the convenience store or corner store, or a remittance service is available where a bank isn’t, customers make the choice for good reasons.

And then third, I think cash is still king at the lowest income levels and immediate access really matters. When a bank places a hold on a check deposit, someone, a lot of families are living, or at least we hear, are living paycheck to paycheck. They can’t always wait several days for that rent or that check to clear to have those funds available. A check casher charges a fee, but that money is right there and the costs are really upfront and known.

And I think sometimes institutions can misunderstand that these are calculated decisions. They’re not always uninformed ones. A flat visible fee can feel a lot safer than an unpredictable overdraft or maintenance fees. In the report, we expound quite a bit on maintenance fees. They’ve increased pretty significantly over the last five to 10 years. So minimums that folks are required to have in the bank are much higher, and it’s not always clear when those fees will be charged.

So I think if a bank really wants to win these customers, they have to really compete on speed, transparency, and be innovative about the types of services they’re thinking that they’re offering. I’ll also say one of the really common, another thing that banks and institutions might miss is that underbanked households, it’s not like they simply don’t trust banks or don’t want to be a part of system. Actually, our data says otherwise. 90% of lower income residents in Massachusetts have an account. And nearly half of the unbanked are actually interested in opening one.

Again, what we’re really happening, I think, is that more than half still use an alternative financial services along those accounts. And that’s not a lack of interest or knowledge. That’s a sign that maybe the products don’t fully fit their needs and they’re filling those gaps other places. So that’s maybe a design problem that banks can solve.

Sergio Galeano

Yeah, just like Nerissa said on driving them to have more innovative solutions. We got a number of questions here and some of them we’ve answered. But they’re hitting on this theme of financial usage among households, the incentives behind some of the fees. So you partly answered this, but someone’s asking here from a financial wellness standpoint, how do we work with participants to ensure that all the money isn’t gone before payday?

So I think they’re getting at a different question that we’ve been answering here, which is access to money, access to tools. Can you have it ready? Can you avoid unnecessary fees? Can you make payments on time? But this is more about financial awareness. And I bring it up because you brought about generational differences, where even if a young person coming out of K-12, high school, college might have mobile banking, they might be very new to earning money using it responsibly.

And there’s a different sort of strategy there. Perhaps storytelling, financial discipline in classes in high school and college, many of which are now mandating it. In terms of generational differences or folks that just became banked, that just started fully participating, is the strategy different? Is the storytelling different from something like you would do typically with someone who the conversation goes to wealth building, doing something with the money you already have?

Jason Andrade

Yeah, no, that’s a great question. I find that especially younger generations in the financial planning work and just anecdotal experience from, I’ve also been a financial coach at a time for the city of Boston, and in some of my previous work. I think especially younger folks are really tying not just basic questions about their financial life and management. But around this larger question, how do I build wealth? How do I leverage these products and accounts? And you’re seeing folks gravitate maybe to Fintechs that are offering that solution. Do I actually think the solutions are always viable? No. But they’re offering this idea of a solution.

I think what’s really important first is we need to help families, and we talk a lot about this, try to not connect to products that are going to strip their wealth. So I think Bank On is a really good solution, something that we stress. What we found is that institutions don’t always do the best job of advertising bank on, so that could create a lack of trust like, “Hey, there is an account that actually would be the right fit, but you put me in this account.” And maybe that’s incentives, that’s a training question. It depends on the institution.

I think it’s also important, it’s important, I talk about social capital a lot in community. It’s important to have meaningful conversations to people about how most folks build wealth, retirement savings, home-ownership and starting a business when you look at historical ways that folks have built wealth in this country. Traditional financial institutions have a real advantage over Fintechs and alternative service providers to earn… They have an opportunity to earn those long-term relationships with clients or customers. And maybe they wrap some of those conversations in the initial account opening process, right? Or when they’re discussing the instant payment services they may offer, right?

So that’s talking about automatic savings, credit building tools that they may offer, retirement options, small business resources. Connecting them to VITA, right? If they are eligible for that, they might have a big savings moment. Maybe they need that bank account at that moment. And I think also just maybe even expanding to talk about other wealth building opportunities like I think 530A or Trump accounts, which are a really good wealth building tool.

Folks maybe are not always trusting or fully knowledgeable about them, and they do trust financial institutions to have the right kind of information for them there. So I think there’s just really thinking less of this transactional framework and more about how are we building relationships. Working with community partners, especially if they have someone in the community that can help them build that trust.

Sergio Galeano

Jason, thank you so much for closing us out with that really comprehensive answer. Again, this was a great panel to bring this all together. A lot of conversations in financial inclusion might focus on the consumer, on the client experience. Getting those accounts out there into communities, helping people understand strategies. Sometimes we have more data-driven, so this together was fantastic.

So whether it was on the new tool the Boston Fed put out or FedNow Instant Payments or the great work that organizations like Jason Andrade are doing, everyone please look out for resources. Some questions in the chat asked about resources, case studies, or surveys. As a reminder, along with the recording, we’ll send you links to everything that was discussed today so that you can follow up. And you’re always welcome to reach out to any of our three speakers. So thank you so much to the three of you for sharing your expertise with us during this webinar.

Now, before we go, I just do have a few requests for everyone in the audience. Please complete the post-event survey. We’ll send it immediately after today’s event so we can continue to improve these, and bring you timely and relevant topics over the year. Materials from today will be available on YouTube and Connected Communities within about two weeks. Please visit the fedcommunities.org website for the resources and links associated with today’s conversation. But also for past webinars on finance, financial inclusion, community development finance, and related topics.

You can always follow us on social media. We’re on LinkedIn, X, Instagram, and Facebook, and you can always subscribe on the Fed Communities newsletter. Besides the recording being available, I do want to share that today concludes our 2026 lineup of event series, but please check out the Events page. We’ll kick right back off the after the holidays with a new set of scheduled webinars on a range of community development topics.

Otherwise, we’ll see you in 2027. Everyone, thank you so much across the country for joining us. Take good care and on behalf of Connecting Communities, we’ll see you soon.